Showing posts with label violation of rights. Show all posts
Showing posts with label violation of rights. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 17, 2010

How I determined to change my life at the age of 19


The above photo was taken of me in my junior year at the University when I was putting into action the plan I had for taking control of my own life. As I saw it most people did not take control of their lives when they were tied to a church like the LDS was at that time. It took too much effort just to follow along and be a good church member. I thought that our own minds were more reliable in telling us what was logical and what was not. It was an archaic idea to let a prophet determine the direction of your life who was long since dead and who had done some pretty bizarre things like introduce polygamy into the church he founded, which ultimately cost him and his brother and 2 others their lives. A mob broke them out of jail back east and killed them because they were incensed with what Joseph Smith was teaching, the principle of polygamy among others.
All the head of the theater department had to do was say that he was Mormon and he was left alone to do whatever he wanted to do. If he lied and cheated on his wife with other men which I suspected him of doing, who was to stop him? Nobody stopped him as long as he professed to be a Mormon. When you have questionable doctrine to wrap your mind around lying and cheating tends to drop to the bottom of the list of transgressions. It is a lot harder to get people to believe that such a bizarre prophet as Joseph Smith really was restoring the only true church back on earth. Joseph Smith believed that all men could become the sons of God. A famous quote from him was, "As God once was, man is, and as God is man can become." I was surprised to learn that this philosophy is touted as being that of the Gnostics who did not believe there was only one son of God as the Christian church later claimed, but that all men were capable of becoming as powerful as Jesus. In other words, he was a standard to measure themselves by and to aspire to emulate. Joseph Smith obviously thought he had risen to a state of progress that was getting close to that of Christ. In fact, in the old days I have heard some Mormons say that they valued the teachings of the prophet in his books above those of Jesus!
This belief circumvents the difficulty of trying to come up with an explanation of how Mary conceived the Son of God. I also have heard the Luke was a Greek who wrote the gospel that refers the most to Jesus being the only true son of God. The Greeks believed their gods could visit mortals and impregnate women a good deal more easily than others believed their gods could, so it was suggested that he was perhaps influenced by Greek beliefs about their Gods in his interpretation of Jesus.
But the fact remains that down through the ages a great many Christians have accepted the beliefs that Jesus is God incarnate and think they are right.
Anyway I am sure that Joseph Smith's revelations resembling the Gnostics philosophy was not lost on some Christians and so the Mormon church came in for a lot of criticism. When they accepted the outlawing of polygamy because the Federal government told them they had to, this criticism died down some. I would say for the most part present day Mormons do not pay that much attention to troubling or illogical aspects of their doctrine, but they are still unable to change it much, since the doctrine sets the Mormon church apart as the only true church, and this is generally speaking what Mormon missionaries are sent to teach.
So I say it is unfortunate when a church so defines a state as Mormonism defines Utah. At one point the church had to close all the seminaries they had built next to public high schools so Mormon students could attend and receive religious instruction for three years before graduating. This was to separate church from state. If you wanted religion in high school you attended a church high school. In Phoenix for example we have St. Marys High School and Brophys, both Catholic high schools. Doc went to a Lutheran High School back in St. Louis.
But whatever thinking I came up with at the university I did not think that I should have been punished by a Mormon psychiatrist to the point of being put under guard and taken off to be locked up! That was way overkill. He should have urged me to seek treatment, but to grab me and incarcerate me when he knew very well that I would be lucky if I escaped electric shock therapy was something like what might have happened in the dark ages. I am sure this is somewhat how the Inquisition did work.
Once I was locked up, the University psychiatrist no longer had jurisdiction over me. I think I saw him once after he had me locked up, and that was not until just a few days before I was released. So the psychiatrists who did see me had to assume that he had good reason for locking me up. I was soon telling them what happened and I was even showing them. If they got very rude I gave them the same treatment, I looked them right in the eye and refused to answer. I figured if I did not treat them the same way I treated him when they said something I did not like, they would never understand what caused him to lock me up. I told them he locked me up for not answering three of his questions! Hey, I did not attack him. I did nothing else to him whatsoever.
And so then their policies regarding incarceration of a person suspected of being mentally ill came into play, especially of a girl only 20 years old. My right to refuse treatment was immediately taken away from me. My parents could sign for it. This could happen all over the country. Mental patients had no rights to refuse treatment. I found that out later in Phoenix. My sister was hospitalized on a volunteer basis in a psych ward. She refused treatment for electric shock therapy. Her husband signed for it and she was given 6 treatments anyway, and from her description they were rough. These were what I feared I was not robust enough to take without severe damage. I had chronic fatigue syndrome of some sort. I told everyone of those doctors this was the main reason they should not give it to me.
Aside from the fact that this was not the right treatment for me. In fact, what in the hell was I doing in there in the first place after a one minute interview?
I was forced to sign a paper saying I volunteered to come into the hospital in order to get out of there after I had almost died.
I regarded what happened to me at the U of U as a far worse violation of my rights than anything that had ever happened to me. This was beyond molesting. This turned out to be life threatening. Those psychiatrists in Utah were just passing out electric shock therapy like crazy.
My theory is that electric shock therapy in all too many cases is just like being locked up as in the days of the Inquisition and being tortured until you come around and are willing to behave better, stop rebelling, and so on. It is tantamount to getting a very bad and scary beating.
I told my dad later in a big argument we got into why don't you get some if you think shock treatments are such good therapy? I was furious at everybody who was responsible for signing for my sister to have electric shock therapy also, as it did not help her an iota. It just made her distrust all psychiatrists exactly as it made me distrust them.
You give psychiatrists or anybody else the power to do things to people against their will on the grounds they are supposed to be mentally ill and what you can get is abuse pure and simple that can be compared to the tactics used in the Inquisition. The more helpless are the ones who get violated. Women. Girls.
I never even went back to see the head of my department. What was the point after so much damage to my health had been done by my incarceration and what I had to do to escape electric shock therapy? I did run into the gay acting student who had become a star and he sneered at me and said, "I have no sympathy for people who imagine their ills (his interpretation of mental illness)" I was still very affected by the whole experience, very fragile, when I went to the University after I came back to my appointment with the Intern at the hospital. This gratuitous cruel remark from him was hard to take, but I figured the way I had left the University had caused enough of a stir he was jealous. I had taken over the limelight for a few days and he did not like it. To be fair, he had a serious illness and died a few years later. If I had not known that I would have had a very tough time forgiving him. He probably told L, the head of my department, he saw me and there wasn't a thing wrong with me, it was so disgusting.
I still was extremely fragile and if I had to undergo too much stress I would begin the dying process all over again. A year and a half later my first husband was drunk and torturing me and after about five hours I started to die. I saw a light come down. Incidentally I thought it might be Jesus in the light. It was somebody pretty powerful who was looking in on this horrific scene. His presence caused me to feel the ecstasy I am sure many have felt who were tortured to death for some reason or another. I was so relieved to see an angel and know they were real and there really was heaven I was going to after death. My husband saw the ecstasy in my eyes and it brought him back to sanity enough for him to stop torturing me. I lay on the bed and went into spasms for two hours. I had very bad nerves, let me tell you. I did not think my body would ever stop jerking.
He sobered up enough to realize that I was going to be easier to kill than most people so if he did not want to be a murderer he better think twice.
I already knew what torture from an alcoholic was. I had seen my dad hold a butcher knife to my mother's throat when he was drunk, asking us girls who were present if we wanted him to kill her. If you are the daughter of an alcoholic as bad as he was, you are going to end up with bad nerves. For this I should be incarcerated and electric shocked? The extreme unfairness of such treatment should be apparent to anybody who isn't power mad or something else seriously wrong with their thinking processes. What makes psychiatrists go bad? Too much power. Some can't handle it. Electric shock therapy passed out to anybody does not require thinking. It is a quick fix. It is like abortion, violent but effective. It gets rid of the problem in a hurry. You don't have to talk to a patient who is getting electric shock therapy. Talk therapy was far too expensive for the poor. If the law allows doctors to violate people's rights some will do it.
That's why the Inquisition killed so many people just for disagreeing with religious doctrine, refusing to be converted, killed for the crime of heresy. At the time it was the easy way to get rid of aggravating heretics around making trouble. Christianity has a very dark history, but many do not want those crimes called to their attention. Believing in the divinity of Jesus did not stop men from torturing and killing those who disagreed, so if all you have to do is say you believe, well this is not a very strong system to keep people from violating other people's rights.
I do not believe that anyone should be severely punished for not believing in certain aspects of religion. But if you believe in the religion too strong, you are going to be convinced that everyone else does not have the right belief system, and this is what can lead to abuse of those who cannot be brought around. At the very least there is rejection and persecution of non believers and critics of the religion.
In Utah, people were very touchy about being criticized for their beliefs outside of Utah, so they were less apt to put up with critics in Utah. Early Mormons were known for sending those who criticized the religion a message to leave, get out of town, etc. Brigham Young even had hopes of creating a Mormon Country, but eventually Mormons were told this was not going to be allowed either. But these policies tended to be carried out later even after Utah became a state. Mormons still aspired to keep Utah Mormon country.
I eventually left the state. It was too difficult to be happy there and not be a Mormon. I disturbed my Mormon relatives who did not rebel. I now live in Arizona which has a large Mormon population, but is contained in cities. There is a big separation between the church and state, but in Utah government officials are generally all going to be elected Mormons because the Mormon population is so large compared to non Mormons.
That is what Brigham Young set out to create after the mob killed Joseph Smith, the founder. He wanted this kind of power.
I should have been lauded for my ability to think for myself, but unfortunately this was not seen as a desirable trait in Utah. I did a great deal of thinking about alcoholism and other social ills, but this thinking was not properly appreciated either.

Tuesday, March 2, 2010

Reading "You Cant Go Home Again," by Thomas Wolfe struck a sad chord in this would be writer's mind even then


I feel a little less agitated now that I have put off indefinitely the plan I had to go to Utah this summer. I am writing in a far too critical way about the past for me to go back among people in my home state I have surely stirred up with my words, but that was bound to happen when I surfaced any history of what transpired in my childhood. I was molested, not once but twice, coming close to a complete breakdown of my nervous system and my general health. I had to suppress these facts for years because telling about the molesting was simply made too difficult. My father although not the molester played a role in agitating the men who did it. He would not allow me to talk about it ever. He was too powerful for me to defy. His alcoholic behavior also caused a great deal of stress not only for me but for my sisters and mother.
I attempted to surface this past while away to college and this attempt resulted in my being incarcerated in a psych ward against my will with electric shock therapy in store for me, a fine way I thought to treat the victim. Because of this incarceration and threat to shock me back to 'normalcy' my health broke down completely and I nearly died in there, but by this happening I was released without being shocked. I was deemed too ill for electric shock therapy, but it was not acknowledged that the threat of it was what brought on my illness, which had its roots in childhood due to stress.
A Mormon psychiatrist put me under guard and incarcerated me after only asking me three questions. I am sure the unorthodox silence that I responded with he saw as insubordination.
I continued to react to insincere questions from other psychiatrists in the mental hospital with silence. I had to go silent to register disagreement and disapproval of their policies of not really taking an interest in talking to the patient if electric shock therapy would do the job without so much investment in time and effort. As a mental patient, I would not have been allowed to disagree with their policies enough to make any difference. I had to go silent to have any hope of taking the discussion of my issues to a deeper level.
Women and young girls in Utah were expected to be even more obedient, respectful, and non critical when men of authority were involved than most. Questioning authority no matter where you found it was just not done.
I believe this attitude to have been retained from the years of polygamy which caused women to become even less equal than they were already. Men could take as many wives as they wanted, while women could aspire to be only one of those wives who must not make waves if polygamous marriages were to work.
Polygamy always produces the lost boys who are left out of the circle because ultimately there are no women for them to marry. The more powerful men in the community would take too many. Mother Nature produces as many boys as girls even in a polygamous society. My father represented one of the lost boys who become the cowboys, the rowdies, the drinkers, the rebels, the non believers, the critics like I was only they drank. Good Mormons girls were warned to stay away from them, so all too often they had to find sexual outlets with each other.
The recent headlines made by the large polygamous cult called the Fundamentalists let the nation see the inside working of an original Mormon society that had refused to give up polygamy. Mainstream Mormons have been accused of being soft on polygamy even as it was given up in the mainstream Mormon church. Polygamy is indeed still on the books as introduced by a prophet who is still worshiped as a man ordained by God to bring the only true church on earth into being. This was the man who introduced polygamy taking women back to a dark place that had not been practiced in civilized society for hundreds of years. I don't even know when and where polygamy was practiced in other cultures as it was in Mormon Utah in the early years.
I still have many relatives active in the Mormon Church, so to leave Utah in order to criticize what is practically a theocracy was to cause a dreadful wrench in my emotions. But I believe that the only way a people can grow who have been born into such a church is to keep trying to accept criticism leveled at its practices and attitudes until they can recast the church into less extremist molds.
Results from deifying kings, emperors and church leaders may sometimes take centuries to rectify. If followers are taught not to criticize but to endlessly support church policy, progress is going to be very slow. Of course a powerful leader may do anything that will support the prophet's claims and keep the organization powerful and the same even when out of step with the rest of the world.
Brigham Young was the powerful man who assumed leadership after Joseph Smith was killed by a mob in Nauvoo, and he led the Mormons to unsettled territory to set up a Mormon state. He wedded 26 wives and had over a hundred children. No potentate in any exotic far East province could have had a more loyal and faithful harem of wives.
No woman who was not obedient and subservient to male authority was going to gain approval in Utah. It was a tradition. I defied that tradition and soon found myself ostracized to the point there was nothing I could do but leave.
My memoirs are about the culture that produces outlaws like my molesters and yes, my father, who although he did not molest me, I thought was capable of involving others in sexual activities, boys, underage or not. I observed him closely for many years and this was the painful conclusion I came to. I did not trust him, but I thought he was only one among many of that kind of outlaw. Generations of them. The lost boys all good Mormon girls were warned to avoid because they broke the word of wisdom, drank, and criticized the church.
Some of them were molesters, some were merely cruel when under the influence as my first husband was. He threatened to kill me many times when drunk and almost succeeded once or twice. Molested. Slapped. Tortured. There is not too much difference in how any of those assaults make you feel. I stopped loving him despite his understanding of a female skeptic. He became too dangerous because of his alcoholism. I had to work a long time on my escape, making sure I was well enough to support our boys by myself if I had to. If I miscalculated and made him too angry I might not live to escape.
He was defended. I was the one who was crazy. I had criticized the church. Stepped out of my role of passive supporter. I had been incarcerated. I was the worst rebel of all. I tried to get him help because of his murderous behavior and suicide threats under the influence while in another state and I was locked up for a week.
Nothing was done to him.
Utah does not have a monopoly on producing men who will attack women who have done nothing to them and who may kill them. Every day there is a murder of a woman in the news. If no one has tried to kill them some women even might say I am exaggerating.
I have feared for my life many times not just in Utah but elsewhere, for there are outlaws everywhere who drink and do drugs, knowing they might get crazy and try to kill somebody. Even if it is in a car on a highway driving too fast while under the influence. A woman who is as outspoken as I am is going to risk a hostile reaction more.
I always praised my sons for their efforts to remain sober and I always have withdrawn to a distance if they drank. I would not allow them to drink in my home. Doc can't drink in my apartment. If he drinks too much and gets crazy I leave his and will not return.
I am willing to work with alcoholics since there are so many of them, but it is a difficult path to walk with male companions who drink too much, who abuse any substance. Drinking is not what they get with me. My biggest problem is food. Which is why I cannot say I am free of substance abuse, because an addiction to food puts on weight, alters the personality and eventually causes severe health problems. I am flawed as well, but I believe that if I write my memoirs and publish them, telling the truth as I see it, I will be doing the world a favor.
We need all the thinking we can get about restraining outlaws and protecting children. We are not aware enough of molesters. Our children may fear to tell us if they are being taken advantage of.
My father did not want to hear about my molesters. He knew about the first one because my mother told him. I first began to talk about him in the mental hospital to a doctor I finally found in there I could trust. He told my parents.
But my father would never allow me to talk about him, probably because he feared I would want to discuss the affair I thought he had been having with the molester. He forcibly kept me from talking about it. He was too threatening for me to be able to do it any way while he was alive. So the writing of my memoirs is long over due.
But I can't go home again. Not now. I am getting people too stirred up. They are finding out what I am saying, and they know the memoirs will be more of the same.
So if I don't want to be shouted at, snubbed, and violently upset I will keep my distance.
It is not an easy thing to seek justice long over due for wrongs that were done to you. Not easy at all.

Herrad

Blog Archive